Investing.com -- Dividend-seeking investors face a challenging landscape as the highest-yielding stocks currently available come with substantial risks, according to a new analysis from WarrenAI. While these stocks offer eye-catching dividend yields, their financial fundamentals suggest potential sustainability issues that investors should carefully consider.
Get premium news and insight, AI stock picks, and deep research tools by upgrading to InvestingPro - get 55% off today
Icahn Enterprises L.P. (NASDAQ:IEP)
The company tops the list with a staggering 24.7% dividend yield, but this comes with serious red flags. The payout ratio stands at an alarming -75.7%, indicating that losses, not profits, are funding the dividends. This unsustainable situation puts the current payout at significant risk.
The stock has declined 7% over the past year and shows negative returns across three-year and five-year timeframes. WarrenAI’s fair value analysis suggests limited upside potential with a -7.6% fair value upside estimate.
In recent news, Icahn Enterprises L.P. reported strong third-quarter 2025 results, with earnings per share of $0.49 and revenue of $2.32 billion, both significantly surpassing analyst expectations.
Global Net Lease, Inc. (NYSE:GNL)
This real estate investment trust offers a 9.2% dividend yield and has maintained dividend payments for six consecutive years. However, the company’s -37.3% net margin raises concerns about long-term sustainability. While revenue growth remains positive at 17.6%, analyst sentiment is divided on the stock’s prospects. WarrenAI calculates a -10.5% fair value upside, suggesting the stock may be currently overvalued.
Global Net Lease, Inc. reported a third-quarter 2025 net loss with an EPS of -$0.33, missing analyst forecasts. Following the results, Citizens reiterated its Market Outperform rating on the company, citing its debt reduction strategy.
SFL Corporation Ltd. (NYSE:SFL)
With a 9.6% dividend yield and a four-year streak of dividend payments, SFL Corporation has managed to achieve a 5% return on invested capital. However, the most troubling metric is its payout ratio of -8436.8%, which clearly indicates that current dividend levels cannot be maintained without a significant financial turnaround. WarrenAI’s fair value analysis shows an -18.1% upside, suggesting substantial overvaluation at current price levels.
SFL Corporation Ltd. announced third-quarter earnings that exceeded analyst expectations, with an EPS of $0.07 on revenue of $178.2 million. Additionally, BTIG raised its price target on the company while maintaining a Buy rating.
While these high-yield dividend stocks may appear attractive at first glance, the underlying financial metrics reveal considerable risks. Negative payout ratios across all three companies indicate that dividends are being funded through means other than sustainable earnings, potentially including debt, asset sales, or cash reserves.
Investors seeking dividend income should weigh these impressive yields against the substantial risk factors identified by WarrenAI’s analysis. The combination of negative margins, unsustainable payout ratios, and negative fair value upside estimates suggests these high yields may come at the cost of future financial stability and potential share price depreciation.
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.








