The Top 5 Analyst Questions From Old Republic International’s Q4 Earnings Call

What Happened?

A number of stocks fell in the afternoon session after the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell as much as 0.7%, reflecting lingering uncertainty, and capping off a volatile week which saw stocks enjoy some relief as President Donald Trump reduced tensions with European allies by backing off his threat of imposing new tariffs. 

Threats of tariffs initially created uncertainty for businesses, as they can lead to higher costs for multinational corporations and disrupt global supply chains. By withdrawing the threat, the administration removed a significant headwind for the market, prompting a relief rally. This development was a key factor in helping major indexes recover from earlier losses, even as some analysts noted that underlying geopolitical risks and market volatility remain concerns for investors.

The stock market overreacts to news, and big price drops can present good opportunities to buy high-quality stocks.

Among others, the following stocks were impacted:

• Life Insurance company F&G Annuities & Life fell 2.6%. Is now the time to buy F&G Annuities & Life? Access our full analysis report here, it’s free.
• Property & Casualty Insurance company Old Republic International fell 2.9%. Is now the time to buy Old Republic International? Access our full analysis report here, it’s free.
• Property & Casualty Insurance company Erie Indemnity fell 3.5%. Is now the time to buy Erie Indemnity? Access our full analysis report here, it’s free.

Zooming In On Erie Indemnity (ERIE)

Erie Indemnity’s shares are not very volatile and have only had 9 moves greater than 5% over the last year. In that context, today’s move indicates the market considers this news meaningful, although it might not be something that would fundamentally change its perception of the business.

The biggest move we wrote about over the last year was 3 months ago when the stock dropped 6.6% on the news that the company reported mixed third-quarter financial results that saw profits beat expectations while revenue fell short. 

The company announced earnings per share of $3.50, which was higher than analysts had forecast and an increase from the $3.06 reported in the same quarter of the previous year. However, revenue for the quarter came in at $1.07 billion, missing the consensus estimate of $1.08 billion. While net income grew compared to the prior year, the market appeared to focus on the sales figures. The negative reaction suggested investor concerns about the revenue shortfall outweighed the positive news of higher profitability during the quarter.

Erie Indemnity is flat since the beginning of the year, and at $275.34 per share, it is trading 38.9% below its 52-week high of $450.61 from March 2025. Investors who bought $1,000 worth of Erie Indemnity’s shares 5 years ago would now be looking at an investment worth $1,158.

Insurance conglomerate Old Republic International reported Q4 CY2025 results topping the market’s revenue expectations, with sales up 9.5% year on year to $2.36 billion. Its non-GAAP profit of $0.74 per share was 16.2% below analysts’ consensus estimates.

Old Republic International (ORI) Q4 CY2025 Highlights:

• Revenue: $2.36 billion vs analyst estimates of $2.32 billion (9.5% year-on-year growth, 1.6% beat)
• Adjusted EPS: $0.74 vs analyst expectations of $0.88 (16.2% miss)
• Adjusted Operating Income: $235.9 million vs analyst estimates of $281 million (10% margin, 16% miss)
• Market Capitalization: $9.52 billion

StockStory’s Take

Old Republic International’s fourth quarter was marked by strong revenue growth but fell short of Wall Street’s profitability expectations, leading to a significant negative market reaction. Management attributed the underperformance to higher loss ratios in commercial auto as well as increased expense ratios from ongoing investments in technology and new specialty operations. CEO Craig Smiddy described the company’s response as “immediate and conservative,” highlighting swift adjustments to loss reserves and a focus on pricing discipline as claim trends deteriorated late in the quarter. The company also noted favorable prior-year reserve development, but this was offset by an unexpected credit loss on a large deductible program within workers’ compensation.

Looking ahead, Old Republic International’s guidance is shaped by expectations of continued premium growth in specialty and title insurance, tempered by persistent claims inflation and a challenging litigation environment in commercial auto. Management emphasized a commitment to maintaining underwriting discipline and pricing actions to keep pace with rising loss trends, particularly in long-haul trucking, where the frequency and severity of bodily injury claims are increasing. CFO Francis Sodaro cautioned that net investment income growth will likely slow in 2026 due to a less favorable interest rate environment. Title insurance is expected to see modest growth, driven by improving commercial activity, while residential markets remain subdued.

Key Insights from Management’s Remarks

Management pointed to a combination of higher claims, litigation pressures, and increased investment in modernization as key influences on quarterly results, while highlighting strategic actions to adapt to market changes.

• Commercial auto loss trends: Management reported that reserve increases in commercial auto stemmed from a rise in bodily injury claims and more cases with attorney involvement, especially in long-haul trucking. CEO Craig Smiddy attributed the spike to what he described as "litigation system abuse" and aggressive plaintiff attorney advertising, leading to a three-point increase in the accident year loss ratio.
• Targeted rate increases: In response to adverse loss trends, Old Republic International accelerated commercial auto rate hikes to 16% in the fourth quarter to maintain alignment with projected loss costs. Smiddy emphasized that the company’s philosophy is to swiftly adjust pricing to reflect updated claims data and keep pace with inflation.
• Expense ratio pressures: The company’s expense ratio rose due to higher spending on technology modernization, data analytics, and artificial intelligence initiatives. These investments, while increasing short-term costs, are expected to provide operational benefits and growth opportunities for the specialty segment over time.
• Specialty operating companies’ contributions: Newly launched specialty operations delivered over $300 million in net premium written during the year and achieved positive operating income, enhancing segment diversification and positioning the company to better manage insurance market cycles.
• Title insurance segmentation: Title insurance growth was strongest in commercial lines, which now account for 29% of earned premiums, up from 23% a year ago. President Carolyn Monroe highlighted ongoing expense management and the rollout of the Qualia technology platform as levers for future efficiency gains.

Drivers of Future Performance

Old Republic International expects a consistent operating environment in 2026, with performance shaped by claims trends, pricing adjustments, and efficiency efforts across its business lines.

• Litigation and claims inflation: Management sees continued pressure from rising claim severities and increased litigation, particularly in commercial auto and long-haul trucking. The company plans to keep underwriting discipline tight and adjust rates as necessary to offset these pressures.
• Technology and operational investment: Ongoing investments in technology, analytics, and the Qualia platform are expected to improve underwriting accuracy and efficiency, but may keep expense ratios elevated in the near term. Management believes these initiatives will support long-term profitability.
• Capital deployment discipline: With $850 million remaining in its share repurchase program and a history of special dividends, Old Republic International intends to remain opportunistic on capital returns, using both buybacks and dividends as tools to manage excess capital while preserving balance sheet flexibility.

Catalysts in Upcoming Quarters

In the coming quarters, the StockStory team will monitor (1) the impact of further commercial auto rate increases and claims trends, (2) execution of technology modernization and the Qualia rollout in title operations, and (3) the pace of capital deployment through buybacks and dividends. The evolution of litigation activity and its influence on loss ratios will also be a critical signpost.

Old Republic International currently trades at $39.11, down from $43.12 just before the earnings. At this price, is it a buy or sell? Find out in our full research report (it’s free).