- XAUUSD
- XAGUSD
- WTI
- USDX
Markets
Analysis
User
24/7
Economic Calendar
Education
Data
- Names
- Latest
- Prev












Signal Accounts for Members
All Signal Accounts
All Contests


Two Libyan Military Sources Said That The Libyan Navy And Air Force Intercepted More Than 12 Unmanned Boats Off The Coast Of Benghazi
Two Libyan Military Sources Said A Maltese-flagged Merchant Ship Was Attacked By A Suicide Drone Boat Off The Coast Of Benghazi, Libya
A Houthi Military Spokesman Said They Attacked A Radar Station In Saudi Arabia’s Duwasser Region
The Pentagon Released A Briefing On Canada's Defense Readiness, Accusing Canada Of Failing To Be A Reliable Partner
Houthi Rebels In Yemen Attacked The Rabigh Oil Refinery On The West Coast Of Saudi Arabia's Red Sea
Joint Maritime Information Center: In The Past 72 Hours, With The Assistance Of The United States, 114 Passage Operations Have Been Completed In The Strait Of Hormuz
U.S. Trade Representative Greer Stated Regarding Trade Negotiations With Canada That He Hopes To Ensure The Protection Of The North American Economy
A Survey Shows That 12 Out Of 14 Economists Expect The Bank Of Israel To Keep Interest Rates Unchanged On Monday; Two Expect A 25 Basis Point Cut To 3.0%
U.S. Trade Representative Greer Stated Regarding The Canada Agreement That The U.S. Is Quite Close To Finding A Solution
U.S. Trade Representative Greer: The United States Is Pushing Forward With Potential Trade Agreements Across Southeast Asia
U.S. Officials Say Cyberattacks Against U.S. Businesses And Infrastructure Will Continue For The Next 18 Months
U.S. Trade Representative Greer: The Agreement With Thailand Will Make It Easier For The U.S. To Sell Pharmaceuticals And Automobiles To Thailand
The UK Maritime Trade Operations Centre Has Received Reports Of An Incident Involving An Oil Tanker And A Military Vessel In The Gulf Of Oman. The Vessel Has Received Updated Maritime Safety Information And Warnings, Reminding All Parties To Be Aware Of The Constantly Changing Maritime Environment. Assessment And Investigation Are Ongoing
Iranian Navy: Ship Owners And Operators Who Disregard Maritime Control Regulations Shall Be Held Liable For All Losses Incurred As A Result
House Democratic Leader Jeffries: Healthcare Is One Area Where Democrats Might Work With Trump

Richmond Federal Reserve President Barkin delivered a speech.
South Korea PPI MoM (Oct)A:--
F: --
Richmond Federal Reserve President Barkin delivered a speech.
U.S. Weekly Treasuries Held by Foreign Central BanksA:--
F: --
P: --
Japan National CPI MoM (Oct)A:--
F: --
P: --
Japan National CPI MoM (Not SA) (Oct)A:--
F: --
P: --
Japan National Core CPI YoY (Oct)A:--
F: --
P: --
Japan National CPI YoY (Oct)A:--
F: --
P: --
Philadelphia Fed President Henry Paulson delivers a speech
U.K. GfK Consumer Confidence Index (Nov)A:--
F: --
P: --
China, Mainland 5-Year Loan Prime RateA:--
F: --
P: --
China, Mainland 1-Year Loan Prime Rate (LPR)A:--
F: --
P: --
Turkey Capacity Utilization (Nov)A:--
F: --
P: --
Turkey Consumer Confidence Index (Nov)A:--
F: --
P: --
Germany PPI MoM (Oct)A:--
F: --
P: --
Germany PPI YoY (Oct)A:--
F: --
P: --
U.K. Core Retail Sales YoY (SA) (Oct)A:--
F: --
U.K. Retail Sales MoM (SA) (Oct)A:--
F: --
U.K. Retail Sales YoY (SA) (Oct)A:--
F: --
ECB President Lagarde Speaks
Mexico Retail Sales MoM (Sept)A:--
F: --
P: --
Canada Core Retail Sales MoM (SA) (Sept)A:--
F: --
Canada Retail Sales MoM (SA) (Sept)A:--
F: --
U.S. UMich Current Economic Conditions Index Final (Nov)A:--
F: --
P: --
U.S. UMich 1-Year-Ahead Inflation Expectations Final (Nov)A:--
F: --
P: --
U.S. UMich Consumer Expectations Index Final (Nov)A:--
F: --
P: --
U.S. UMich Consumer Sentiment Index Final (Nov)A:--
F: --
P: --
Euro Zone Consumer Confidence Index Prelim (Nov)A:--
F: --
P: --
U.S. Weekly Total Oil Rig CountA:--
F: --
P: --
U.S. Weekly Total Rig CountA:--
F: --
P: --
Australia Composite PMI Prelim (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
Australia Manufacturing PMI Prelim (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
France Services PMI Prelim (SA) (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
France Manufacturing PMI Prelim (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
France Composite PMI Prelim (SA) (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
Germany Composite PMI Prelim (SA) (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
Germany Services PMI Prelim (SA) (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
Germany Manufacturing PMI Prelim (SA) (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
Euro Zone Composite PMI Prelim (SA) (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
Euro Zone Services PMI Prelim (SA) (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
Euro Zone Manufacturing PMI Prelim (SA) (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
U.K. Composite PMI Prelim (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
U.K. Services PMI Prelim (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
U.K. Manufacturing PMI Prelim (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
Mexico Economic Activity Index YoY (Sept)--
F: --
P: --
Canada National Economic Confidence Index--
F: --
P: --
U.S. Chicago Fed National Activity Index (Oct)--
F: --
P: --
U.S. IHS Markit Manufacturing PMI Prelim (SA) (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
U.S. IHS Markit Composite PMI Prelim (SA) (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
U.S. IHS Markit Services PMI Prelim (SA) (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
U.S. 2-Year Note Auction Avg. Yield--
F: --
P: --
Japan Manufacturing PMI Prelim (SA) (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
Germany IFO Business Climate Index (SA) (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
Germany Ifo Business Expectations Index (SA) (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
Germany Ifo Current Business Situation Index (SA) (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
U.K. CBI Distributive Trades (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
U.K. CBI Retail Sales Expectations Index (Nov)--
F: --
P: --
U.S. Weekly Redbook Index YoY--
F: --
P: --
U.S. FHFA House Price Index MoM (Sept)--
F: --
P: --
U.S. S&P/CS 20-City Home Price Index YoY (Not SA) (Sept)--
F: --
P: --













































No matching data
A better-than-VWAP fill can coexist with a costly unfinished decision. Reconcile an original 1,200-share example, including delay, execution, fees and the shares never bought, without double-counting the cost of waiting.
A buy order can beat the market’s volume-weighted average price and still leave the portfolio worse off than the original investment decision implied. There is no contradiction: the fill-price comparison covers the shares bought, while the decision also includes shares that never traded. Implementation shortfall measures that wider gap. The useful question is not whether one benchmark makes the trade look good, but whether the full cash-and-position ledger reconciles. The stock, prices and fees below are hypothetical.

At 10:00, an investor decides to buy 1,200 shares at a recorded reference price of $50.00. The order reaches the execution process at 10:02, when the arrival reference is $50.08. Two lots fill; the remaining 500 shares are canceled at a predeclared 15:00 valuation cutoff, when the reference price is $50.40.
| Order outcome | Shares | Fill price | Cash spent before fees |
|---|---|---|---|
| First fill | 400 | $50.10 | $20,040 |
| Second fill | 300 | $50.16 | $15,048 |
| Unfilled remainder | 500 | No fill | $0 |
The 700 executed shares cost $35,088, giving a volume-weighted fill price of $50.125714. Add an assumed $7 in explicit fees. No financing interest, tax, currency movement or dividend is included. Those items would need separate treatment if present.
The decision price and arrival price refer to different timestamps in this example. A midpoint or other reference is a measurement convention, not proof that all 1,200 shares were executable there. Record the chosen quote source, order size and capacity assumptions; a benchmark built on impossible liquidity cannot become evidence of guaranteed attainable performance.
Start both portfolios with $60,000. The paper portfolio buys all 1,200 shares at $50.00 and ends with $60,480 at the cutoff, a $480 gain. The actual portfolio spends $35,095 including fees, retains $24,905 cash and holds 700 shares worth $35,280. Its ending value is $60,185, a $185 gain.
Implementation shortfall = $60,480 − $60,185 = $295. This is a cost relative to the paper decision, not an actual cash loss of $295: the actual portfolio still gained $185 over the stated window.
The same result comes from the order ledger. Executed-price slippage is 400 × ($50.10 − $50.00) + 300 × ($50.16 − $50.00) = $88. The unfilled opportunity component is 500 × ($50.40 − $50.00) = $200. Add $7 fees to reach $295.
Expressed against the intended decision notional, the cost is $295 ÷ $60,000 × 10,000 = 49.17 basis points. A filled-only report instead shows $95 ÷ $35,000 × 10,000 = 27.14 basis points. That figure is not arithmetically wrong, but it covers a different quantity and denominator. It cannot stand in for the full-decision cost.
One consistent attribution measures delay only on shares that eventually filled, then measures the unfilled shares over the entire decision-to-cutoff period. With arrival at $50.08, the breakdown is:
| Component | Calculation | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Delay on filled shares | 700 × (50.08 − 50.00) | $56 |
| Execution versus arrival | 400 × (50.10 − 50.08) + 300 × (50.16 − 50.08) | $32 |
| Unfilled opportunity | 500 × (50.40 − 50.00) | $200 |
| Explicit fees | Recorded net charges | $7 |
The sum is $295. Another valid convention assigns delay to all intended shares: 1,200 × 0.08 = $96. If so, the remaining-share component must start at arrival, becoming 500 × (50.40 − 50.08) = $160. The total remains $96 + $32 + $160 + $7 = $295.
Combining the $96 delay with the original $200 opportunity term produces $335, overstating cost by $40. It counts the first $0.08 movement on 500 unfilled shares twice. Different attribution labels are acceptable; an unreconciled ledger is not. Also, the $32 execution term is not a clean estimate of the order’s causal market impact: unrelated news and price movements can contribute.
Suppose market VWAP for the specified execution window is $50.18. Buying the executed 700 shares at that benchmark would cost $35,126. The actual pre-fee spend of $35,088 is $38 better, or $31 better after the $7 fee. The trader has beaten that VWAP comparison while the full decision still shows $295 shortfall.
VWAP answers a useful but narrower question about prices during a selected interval. State the window, venues, eligible prints, auction treatment and whether the investor’s trades enter the benchmark. A benchmark influenced by one’s own order is not an independent control. Nor should an attractive fill-only score hide a low completion rate.
This does not make VWAP intrinsically bad. A mandate seeking participation through a session may value it; a time-sensitive decision may care more about pre-trade prices and completion. Choose the benchmark to fit the purpose before execution, rather than choose the most flattering benchmark afterward.
Let Q be intended quantity, qᵢ each fill, pᵢ its price, p₀ the decision reference and pT the fixed endpoint price. Use s=+1 for a buy and s=−1 for a sell. With the same-currency and no-financing assumptions above:
Shortfall = s × [Σ qᵢ(pᵢ−p₀) + (Q−Σ qᵢ)(pT−p₀)] + net explicit costs.
For a mirrored sale, take decision price $50.00, arrival $49.92, fills of 400 at $49.90 and 300 at $49.84, cutoff $49.60 and fees $7. Selling below the decision reference costs $88; the unsold 500 shares lose $200 relative to the paper sale. Fees add $7, again giving $295. Do not multiply the fee by the side sign.
Opportunity cost can also be negative. Keep the original buy fills and fees, but consider a separately specified scenario with cutoff price $49.80: the unfilled component is −$100, and total shortfall is −$5. That is a benefit relative to the benchmark, not proof that the portfolio made money or that waiting is always superior. Changing the endpoint after seeing the price would invalidate the comparison.
Keep the parent decision, intended quantity, timestamps, order revisions, fills, fees and final valuation in one audit trail. Cancellation does not erase the unfilled quantity from the original decision. A genuine change of investment view should be recorded when it happens, with a new decision segment where appropriate, rather than rewritten after the outcome. Reconcile cancellation acknowledgments and late fills so that replacement orders are not counted twice.
The mechanics behind incomplete orders are explained in limit prices, queue priority and partial fills. A price cap may reduce the price paid on fills while leaving exposure unimplemented. Faster trading may improve completion but raise spread or impact costs; neither speed nor patience is universally optimal.
Finally, compare like with like: order size relative to liquidity, urgency, volatility, trading window and completion requirements. Report completion rates and the distribution of shortfall across comparable orders, not just a single average. A one-order calculation can expose a bookkeeping mistake; it cannot by itself establish misconduct, identify causal impact or rank a broker’s skill.
The risk of loss in trading financial instruments such as stocks, FX, commodities, futures, bonds, ETFs and crypto can be substantial. You may sustain a total loss of the funds that you deposit with your broker. Therefore, you should carefully consider whether such trading is suitable for you in light of your circumstances and financial resources.
No decision to invest should be made without thoroughly conducting due diligence by yourself or consulting with your financial advisors. Our web content might not suit you since we don't know your financial conditions and investment needs. Our financial information might have latency or contain inaccuracy, so you should be fully responsible for any of your trading and investment decisions. The company will not be responsible for your capital loss.
Without getting permission from the website, you are not allowed to copy the website's graphics, texts, or trademarks. Intellectual property rights in the content or data incorporated into this website belong to its providers and exchange merchants.
Not Logged In
Log in to access more features
Log In
Sign Up